‘Non-UPF Verified’ Standard Aims to Rebuild Trust in Processed Foods

The Food Integrity Collective (FIC) unveiled the first iteration of its Non-UPF Verified standards during an exclusive webinar on Wednesday, detailing the permitted processes and ingredients it believes are essential to incentivizing the food industry to reprioritize naturalness and less processing in the food supply. The standards will be made available to the public on November 12.
“This whole program brings visibility to the one thing that the package doesn’t yet show, which is how the food was actually made,” stated Megan Westgate, founder and CEO of the Non-GMO Project as well as the newly established Food Integrity Collective, the latter of which has spent the past year designing a standard and industry parameter for ultraprocessed foods.
The standard addresses product manufacturing from two angles, first by assessing the processing of ingredients and the end product as a whole, as well as setting requirements around ingredient integrity and formulation. The initial version of the standard encompasses ingredient classes including sugar, gums, thickeners and emulsifiers, natural flavors and refined oil and sodium.
“Not all processing is equal,” Westgate said during the webinar presentation. “The Non-UPF Verified standard distinguishes between minimal, conditional and prohibited processing methods requiring that products be composed primarily of minimally processed ingredients and free from high-impact chemical, structural, thermal and biological modification. These limits are applied both to individual ingredients and to the product as a whole.”
Westgate emphasized an important distinction about the existing NOVA classification and its use in establishing the Non-UPF standards; she said that while NOVA created a shared language for talking about and researching UPFs, it is not an auditable, verifiable or actionable framework as it applies blanket classifications to food categories while not deliberating on processing intensity or specific formulations.
The Non-UPF verification was designed with a combination of market research, nutritional science, and input from food and beverage manufacturers across a range of categories with the goal of incentivizing food manufacturers to reformulate toward more natural and wholesome foods. She also acknowledged that this initial version of the standards is highly likely to change as FIC continues to learn and take comments from the industry.
Over the past 10 months, 16 brands, including Amy’s Kitchen, Simple Mills and Spindrift, participated in a pilot program to help FIC better understand how processing methods are applied, acceptable use cases for specific ingredients and what constitutes a responsible amount of documentation to audit and certify a product.
The Standards
As a baseline, 70% of any Non-UPF Verified product must be considered minimally or moderately processed. That remaining 30% allows for conditionally processed ingredient inclusions like starches, protein powder and other more processed inputs that are often added in “good faith” and may have a structural function in improving the healthfulness of a product.
“People have different opinions about how effective [something like added protein powder is], but we didn’t want to completely ban that because a lot of products that people are looking toward to support their metabolic wellbeing do include some more processed ingredients,” Westgate explained.
Any foods containing synthetic biology-produced inputs, 3D printed foods, or ingredients resulting from industrial fermentation processes are not allowed in any item carrying the Non-UPF Verified seal. The standard contains a “harmonized” list of prohibited ingredients, which comprises “quality standards and governmental regulations, including European Union regulations, PCC Community Markets, Whole Foods Market, and applicable U.S. state legislation.”
The Sugar Cap: Added sugar limits have been determined per food category. For example, desserts cannot feature added sugars that exceed 20% of the weight of the product, while breakfast foods are restricted to 15%, dairy and dairy-alternatives to 7% and beverages to 5%.
“We know that the incredible overconsumption of sugar is a huge driver in the metabolic dysfunction that we’re seeing at the population level, and is a huge driver of why UPFs are so detrimental to health,” Westgate said. “It felt really important to us to figure out a way to address that with this aim to drive realistic reformulation.”
Non-nutritive sweeteners and sugar alcohols are banned with one exception for whole leaf or minimally processed stevia products; these banned sweeteners include aspartame, acesulfame K, sucralose, as well as brazzein, thaumatin, monk fruit extract, erythritol, xylitol and sorbitol, among others. Considering driving reformulation is the goal; Westgate said Non-UPF Verified did not want to “inadvertently drive the food supply toward one where there’s a bunch of sugar replacements that the jury is still out on.”
The standards allow for minimally processed sugar like honey and coconut sugar to be added without limitation to verified products.
“What we’re seeing is that there is a trend toward much less processed sugar, and that there is also an important correlation between metabolic response and glycemic index,” said Westgate. “Those less processed sugars have a lower glycemic index [showing] there is a relationship there with the health and the degree of processing.”
Gums, Thickeners and Texturizers: The program places an outright ban on most traditional gums, gelling agents and emulsifiers such as carrageenan and polysorbates. Any product containing gums made via industrial fermentation, enzymatic hydrolysis, or other high-impact processing – such as xanthan gum, gellan gum or maltodextrin – are ineligible for Non-UPF verification.
However, a handful of gums are permitted for conditional use, meaning documentation is required demonstrating there are no viable, less processed alternatives. Inputs like guar gum, locust bean gum, tara gum, pectin, tamarind seed gum and others are permitted in small quantities only when functionally necessary and in limited use cases, such as suspending or stabilizing added nutrients and liquids, Westgate said.
The Flavor Debate: In version one of the Non-UPF standards, natural flavors are considered an “optional” category for obtaining verification and is one aspect of the program that is most likely to evolve in future iterations. The looser restrictions around flavors were set to “avoid unnecessary barriers for adoption,” Westgate said, and to allow the Non-UPF team to continue to better understand this “highly variable and opaque ingredient class.”
However, brands using natural flavors and seeking certification must provide full disclosure of their flavor use and documentation to help the program determine where the “right line” is for natural flavor use cases. The standard does offer an exception for “traditional single source extracts” such as vanilla extract or citrus oils.
“Natural flavors are in scope of our consideration because one of the core hallmarks of ultraprocessed food is this mismatch between the sensory experience of eating it and what’s actually in the product,” Westgate explained.
The standard’s core principle around natural flavors is that it wants to push industry to only use these ingredients when “the corresponding real ingredient is also present in a greater amount.” This practice would eliminate natural flavors being used to “stimulate, imply or replace ingredients,” or mask and enhance the sensory experience, which are key attributes of UPFs.
Oil and Salt: This final ingredient class brings the widest delta between NOVA and the Non-UPF standards, with Westgate explaining that certifier does not believe it is beneficial to lump fat, sodium and sugar together as “core hallmarks of UPF” since fat and sodium are “essential to human biological function.”
The standard’s view on refined oil focuses largely on the how the oil was made; hydrogenated and industrial processed oils are banned entirely while refined, bleached and deodorized oils, as well as others, are restricted to conditional use and cannot exceed more than 30% of the product formulation.
Sodium is treated in a similar manner with the degree of processing behind the sodium ingredient determining whether or not the product can be deemed Non-UPF. Industrially processed sodium sources like MSG are not allowed in any amount, while naturally occurring sodium from whole or minimally processed foods are permitted and the amount of inclusion is unrestricted.
“[A sodium limit] is something that we explored and considered in an early draft of the standard, and with consideration for the health research, the market research and the realities of the food supply, it just felt like it wasn’t helpful or useful to restoring naturalness and less processing to our food… so we don’t have one. This isn’t just a label. It’s a shift in how food is made. We’re aiming to restore integrity to processed food, instead of rejecting it outright.”
Explore the Nombase CPG Database
Head to Nombase to learn more about the tagged companies and their offerings.