Skip to main content

The Trade Spending Tidal Wave & How to Ride It, Sponsored by UpClear

The Trade Spending Tidal Wave & How to Ride It, Sponsored by UpClear
Featuring: Kurt Kaiser, Business Development Leader, UpClear

Transcript

Note: Transcripts are automatically generated and may contain inaccuracies and spelling errors.

Kurt Kaiser [00:13] All right, good afternoon, everybody. Uh, it is afternoon, I think. Uh, my name's Kurt Kaiser. Uh, I am with a company called Up Clear. And the way that you can think about Up Clear is we are a software company that provides an operating system for your salesforce. Not yours Salesforce because you're a retailer. But, uh, uh, the topic we're gonna talk about today is, uh, is trade spending. Now, 25+ years ago, I said to myself, what is the topic that is universally hated in consumer goods? And I said, I'm gonna make a career out of that. Uh, uh, in all, in all, uh, all joking aside, um. So, uh, I've been in the industry a long time, kind of broken up into three phases. I worked on the big brand side for about a decade. Another chunk of time I spent at Nielsen working on pricing and promotion analytics, and then, uh, the rest in, uh, trade promotion management space, which is the kind of the name of the products. That, uh, kind of fits this, this space. Tidal wave trade spending, does this resonate with anybody here? Well, it will, if it doesn't yet. So we're going to talk about trade spending and um. Like 4 categories. So first we're gonna, um, kind of define the tidal wave. Um, we're gonna talk about some of the conditions that lead to what is typically considered chaos, uh, and then just talk about some strategies and then, uh, and then tools, right? And what's in, in surfing, right, your tool is a surfboard. Before we dive into this, um, you know, in our picture up here, we have an environment where these surfers are, are going to surf, right? So we're gonna talk about the environment, um, for this discussion, OK. So first of all, Uh, I'm gonna be talking about retail channels, OK? So what we're not talking about in this is any direct to consumer. Uh, I'm not talking about food service. There's plenty of solutions out there for, for these things, uh, but those are out of scope for today. Next is, I think what everybody is, is here for fast moving consumer goods or you want to be very fast moving consumer goods. Um, so we're talking about groceries for the most part, OK. Next is highly promoted categories, right? This is where you're spending money on promotions. So we're not talking about electronics, we're not talking about uh apparel, we're not talking about Weber grills. When's the last time you saw a promotion for a Weber grill? They don't have to Uh, but for everybody else, um. We're talking about trade spending. And then the last thing. is customer-specific spending, OK? So this is money that you're, uh, you're spending with your customers like our friends from Whole Foods here. Um, and what we're not talking about is brand advertising, OK? So that's kind of the environment that, uh, that we're gonna be discussing here today. Right, the wave OK, so maybe this is a better picture of a wave for our industry. Right? It's a lot of money. And if you're not at this point yet, you probably will be soon. Uh, 25% is a, uh, pretty typical, uh, rate of trade spending rate of gross revenue. Uh, for brands that, uh, get national distribution, um, and spend a lot of money promoting their products. And it doesn't start out to be 25% of gross revenue, right? It's a build over time, right? And so what's in this wave we're talking about the money that is spent on customer promotions. So these are bill backs off invoice allowances, MCBs, right? And you have, you have money that you spend at distributors, you have money that is spent at retailers, uh, you have money that's spent at indirect retailers. Um, and then there's customer marketing programs. What else are we talking about? Slotting. Right? So Um, different companies will have different definitions of where slotting fits exactly, right? But I'm including it in this because it's an investment that you're making with your customer. Next Damages, fines, fees. OK? So this, this is a little bit outside of the trade spending definition, but we're including it here because. This is money that um. Uh, these, these are things that you also receive deductions for as a brand. Right? When, when you get your remittance in, and there's deductions for trade spending for promotions, there's deductions also for damages and, uh, uh, logistics fines, logistics fees, shortages, right? That's, that's all in the mix here. Right? And With all due respect to our retail friends, there's errors in some cases. Uh, and, um, these are all things that contribute to this, this wave of of trade spending building over time. All right. Conditions. So what conditions lead to this tidal wave? We see some ominous clouds out there, not unlike, uh, our view of the beach today. OK, first one is growing distribution. OK. So, uh, as a brand grows and starts to get traction, um, You, you want to add customers, but that is a contributor to this tidal wave, uh, forming. And with those more customers come more promotions. OK. And with those uh promotions come more spreadsheets and more approval processes and, uh, more money out the door. And with more promotions. Come more deductions. OK. I'm sure this is all, um, hopefully familiar territory here. And then the last thing that uh contributes to the tidal wave is more people, right? As your team grows you're adding resources to grow your business, right? But it, it ends up being a contributing factor to uh the growth of trade spend. Because these people now have to be part of the process. They have to, uh, um, they have to negotiate with your customers. Um, there is, there's more work to do, and it becomes a more difficult process. So what are the wipeouts? Right? So not everybody rides the wave, uh, immediately. So what, what kind of things happen, um, that we would kind of think of as wipeouts? So the first is, is, and the biggest is gross margin degradation. Right, so, uh, uh, uh, my argument for good control of trade spending is that it's going to enable you to maintain gross margin. Right? If gross margin is, uh, gross profit divided by net sales. Right? The gross sales, gross revenue, right? That's part of both of those equations, the, the, the numerator and the denominator. Right? And then net sales. The other variable is trade spending. Gross minus trade is net sales. Right? And if your trade spending is outpacing your gross revenue, uh, that's going to become an issue for gross margin. So let's say there's some gross margin issues, right? So Then the challenge becomes, uh, what am I spending my money on, right? And if you don't have good control of trade spending, if you don't have information, you don't have data. You're not gonna know what you're spending your money on, right? And that, that's uh a way that uh businesses wipe out. And I've seen the the movie or remember the movie Point Break. Right, um, I think his name was Body. Body was a bank robber, right? I'm not suggesting your sales team is gonna, gonna rob the rob the bank or rob you, but, but a challenge, uh, becomes, uh, keeping your sales teams, uh, doing the things that you want them to do. Right? And, and not, uh, going rogue, not extending offers that you don't want extended. And then finally, and probably the thing I see most often when people come looking for help in this space is that AR uh gets, gets gnarly. Right, uh, the most likely model that we see is, is, um, An accounts receivable rep that is the person that's, uh, taking a look at all the deductions that come in. And they're the one charged with validating these deductions and trying to understand if, if, if it's a good, good deduction, if it's earned or not earned. And as those conditions, uh, build up, right, and distribution is growing, and more people are involved in the process, and there's more, there's more, uh, promotions taking place. Right, that person is going to get overwhelmed very, very quickly. Um And as I said, that's tends to be one of the, the, the indicators or one of the, the triggers for companies to come and look for help. So how, how then do we ride. The wave So We've got a room here full of very smart people, so. You're gonna hear some familiar concepts here, right? And you might be doing some of these, so hopefully this is reinforcement of things that you're already doing, but if you're not, right, this is potentially just a road map of, of how you can uh take a look at trade spending and um. And avoid the wipeouts. Because ultimately. You do want the wave, right? You're, you want the wave because you want your sales to grow. And some of this is going to come with it. But when you get to the point where. Uh, you have to make some decisions. You need to understand what's in that wave and why it's gotten so big. So first of all, um, first strategy for riding the wave is to declare your strategy. And Strategies For consumer brands, you know, in this, in this space are pretty clear cut. It's either maximize growth or maximize profit. And it's hard to do both. So we, we do believe that you need to be declarative about this. And when you're in a, a drive growth phase, you're gonna spend money, right? You're going to spend money because you want people to try your products and you're using promotions to, to get trial. Um, But at some point, you're going to switch to a maximized profit. Uh, strategy, and when you do that, the questions that you're going to be asked are, where can we get more efficient. And then when you need to know when, uh, where you can get more efficient. Then you need to know how your promotions have performed. This is not brain, uh, brain surgery, rocket science. You wanna do more of what is, uh, working and less of what doesn't. Right? In order to do that, you, you need to have the ability to understand how your promotions are performing. So, in a, in a, um. In a report like this, let me just describe what we're looking at here. Uh, the three things that you're usually most interested with a promotion, your sales, your trade spending, and what you're getting back from it. OK? So, in this example, we're kind of uh drilling down from, uh, across customers, right down to brands, and then down to specific promotions, right? And. What you're able to do with this is identify what's working and what's not working. Right? There is, there's good spending and there's bad spending and, and, uh, I'm, I'm yet to see any brand totally get rid of, you know, what they might consider to be uh bad spending. Right, but In order to know. Uh What spending is good, what spending is bad, right? You need some data. Next, uh, suggestion, next recommendation is to understand your trends. Again, an illustration here, um, what we're looking at is a, um, a point of sale report. So this is like Nielsen data. And in a report like this, what you're able to do is, uh, first look at your sales trends, right? You can then see, uh, the type of promotion, execution that's taken place. Um, you can see the price points. And what this allows you to do is learn about your performance. It's going to enable you to see, uh, see a trends in your, in your sales. Um, it's gonna enable you to understand how well you plan. Right, and it's gonna enable you to um learn about your environment. Um, competitors, um. Seasonality of your products. So understanding trends is gonna help you, um, both understand your, your situation, your dynamics today, and help you plan better for the future. Next suggestion, next recommendation, next strategy is, is negotiate everything, both internally and externally. Right, and. Uh, you know, as business leaders, you guys are, um. Uh, when it relates to promotions you're going to be asked, um. If you're, if you're OK with, uh, promotions being run, right? And our, our suggestion, our recommendation is that when you're asked that question you should be able to, uh, to negotiate with your internal team as well as your customers, right? In order to do that you need information, you need facts. Right? And you should be able to, uh, to be able to answer these kinds of questions. Uh, what slotting rates am I paying across customers? What are the rules? Right, there's, uh, you know, rules that will accompany freefill agreements. I remember working with one customer with one brand, uh, that had a, a massive freefill deal, uh, and then his product didn't quite sell through and then they returned it and he had to pay. He had to pay the return. And that was the rules, that was the rules that were established for that. Uh, so know what you're getting yourself into. Um, off invoice, right? Off invoice is really a, it's a subsidy on your list price. Right? You're, you're basically just dropping your list price, right? So when you do that, I'm not saying don't do it, but when you do, uh, understand how that plays out across customers. So you can ask your, your rep, your, your sales team that that question. Uh, everyday prices, right? Everybody wants to, uh, to manage price. Everybody wants to, um, be competitive with price, right? Having the data at your fingertips to, to understand, uh, pricing, price gaps, uh, that's, that's again something that you should be able to, uh, challenge your team back on. Same with profit margins, you know, most, most, uh, um, most of us can guesstimate, um, a, a retailer's margin based on what we're offering them, what they're selling their, the product at, what their dead net price is. Right. So you've got the information to understand what that is across customers, and you should use that. Um, depth of discount. Same thing. You're, you're, you're running promotions across customers, and you have your everyday price and a promoted price, right? So all, all of these are, are, are elements of trying to keep that tidal wave from getting unmanageable, right? And, and in our analogy here, our metaphor, letting you ride it. Uh, accountability. Again, I'm quite sure you guys are doing this, right? Targets you need targets for spending. Most, uh, most of us will use a, a rate-based target. Um, sales targets. Um, If you're really, uh, if you're really ambitious, you might go to a net sales target. Um, but set targets, hold your team accountable for, uh, delivering the business. Um, guidelines, uh, this is, this is, I, I think a really important element of this is, is to set up, uh, uh, put your, your post in the ground on, on what you're expecting. What kind of frequency do you want? Uh, for promotions, what kind of depth of discount do you look for? Uh, how do you wanna be priced versus your competition? Another part of accountability is approvals and, and making sure that you have an approval process in place. So that, um, again, people aren't extending offers that, uh, you don't want extended. And all of that, uh, needs to be integrated with their personal objectives, you know, it, it's, um. Uh, it's one thing to, to, to have it in the, the everyday, uh. Uh, business plan, right? But at the end of the day, these folks are part of your team. And we suggest making these volume targets, making these spending targets, making the net sales targets part of the, the, uh, the overall performance process. And again, these are, these examples are, are um some tools that you can apply to, uh, to help measure that. And then the last thing, um, we mentioned deductions before, uh, manage the deductions before they manage you. Uh, this is, uh, if, if you're not, uh, in this space yet, this is probably gonna be one of the, the, the first. Um, hurdles that you'll, you'll, you'll face. The, the quantity of deductions that your accounts receivable person is going to have to manage as your distribution grows is, um, is gonna just grow exponentially. So prepare for that, right? I think back to my, my, uh, single, uh, project management class that I took many, many years ago where you've got a triangle and you've got, uh, scope and you have time and you have resources and the outcome of that is quality, right? If you have one person that's, that's, uh, executing this process and. Their work. Doubles, quadruples, um, you can't expect the right, the same quality out of that process. Right? And what happens then is you'll start taking shortcuts and you'll, you'll set, um, you'll start setting a threshold and you'll say, I'm just not gonna deal with anything that's, uh, below this dollar threshold because I, I can't, I don't have the time to process it. Right? So there's ways that you can become more efficient in this deduction management, uh, space. The other thing with with regard to deductions that I think is a really um. Unappreciated opportunity. Is the ability to identify the actual cost of promotions. So what do I mean by that? Uh, what's very, very common for a deduction process is, um. Kind of a validation, right? There'll be the deduction and the remittance, and there's kind of a check, check box. Was it planned? Was it approved? Is it OK? Right. And that, that, uh, a lot of times is the end of the end of the story. OK. What you're missing, if that's all you're doing is, uh, you're missing the opportunity to identify the actual spending of the promotions that you're executing. Because all of that information is, is there. It's buried in that paperwork. Uh, and then distribute the work, right? So don't make this the responsibility of just one person. And, uh, you know, as, as this happens, this is, this is also where you tend to want tools to help. Um, Emails, spreadsheets become cumbersome and, uh, and not sustainable, right? And this is an area where tools like what we deliver can help out. Uh, picking the right board. So what you want your tool set to, to do is, uh, the stuff that you see listed up here. You want to be able to uh uh create accountability. You want to, uh, facilitate control of the process. You wanna standardize things across your, your team, your customers. Uh, centralization, right? So. Instead of having, uh, uh, you know, 10 spreadsheets that collect data, right? You want to centralize that into one repository. You wanna create efficiency and ultimately you wanna create those insights that help you, uh, understand your business and, uh, and make better decisions. And those tools, tool sets tend to fall into two categories. One is Excel and email and text messages and phone calls, right? Or a platform called Trade promotion management. Right, which is one of the, one of the things that uh that Upclear does. Right, um And you know, being a, a salesperson, right? I'm, I'm here to dispel some, some myths, right? Um, you know, there's, there's one, rationalization that I hear quite often that, you know, promotions are a cost of doing business. I have to do them. Right? So, uh, I'm just gonna, I, I don't want to encumber this with, with, uh, with, uh, tools that, uh, are gonna take up too much time. It's not 2020, uh, 2010 anymore, right? There's, there's, uh, plenty of, of, of, uh, options out there that, uh, will help you get that process done. Uh, more efficiently. Takes too much time. It's too complicated. At the end of the day, all of these tend to be trade-offs. So, uh, you certainly as as business teams, you have priorities, right? And priorities are gonna range from. Uh, procurement of your ingredients, right, to, uh, other overhead to trade spending, um, and, and those things are gonna fall in a pecking order, right? Our, uh, our suggestion is to think about this not as a, um, necessarily, uh, a capital investment or an expense. This is a way to help you keep control of 20% of your gross revenue. Uh, an expense that's equal to 20% of your gross revenue. Right? And then, um. You know, uh, with regard to, to the, to the options that are available for, uh, this space, right, it's, it's not, uh, uh, again, it's, it's not where it's not a, uh, uh, uh, a dynamic where it's, uh. Uh, tens of thousands of dollars a month to, uh, have a system that helps with this space, right? There's solutions out there. We break ours into, into three levels, um, that tend to provide, uh, a right fit for the right size brand. Right. And just wrap up our, again, our company is called UpClear. Our platform is called Blue Planner, and we play in these, uh, four spaces, trade permission management, that's primarily what we've been talking about. Optimization is, uh, adding additional analytics into that space. Integrated business planning is, uh, uh, making connections with other, other teams inside of your four walls. Whether it's uh demand planning or finance. Uh, and then, uh, revenue growth management is a, uh, set of, uh, advanced analytics that help you understand, uh, the total picture of your pricing and promotion investments. So, uh, that's. A little bit about, uh, riding that wave, how you can uh avoid wipeouts and, uh, see a, uh, a path to growth in your business. Thank you very much.

Speaker 2 [28:25] Open it up to Q&A if anyone has questions, please take advantage of. expert Got a mic.

Speaker 3 [28:34] There you go. Uh, every time I think about promotions, I just get depressed because I just can't see a way out of all of the tragedies that you posted in this, in, in this presentation, the billbs, like things that come up, uh, things you have to fight and to validate, as you said, like how do brands actually make money, like small brands that are just entering into, um, retail, like I, you know.

Kurt Kaiser [29:05] Uh, I, I don't, anybody else want to take a stab at that answer? Volume. Yeah. Yeah, uh, um, velocity. Right, and, and it's, it's that, um. That delicate balance, right, as you're growing, uh, you know, of incentivizing the shopper to try your product, right? And then keep buying it. Um, so, uh, you know, that, like I said before, the wave is going to be there. You, you want the wave, right? But you, you want to be able to ride it. You don't wanna, you don't want to wipe out. Other questions?

Speaker 4 [29:44] Um, thank you. Um, how would you kind of discuss, uh, aside from the numbers, um. Keeping promotions with just to keep uh relationships with the retailers that you know a lot of times during the pandemic because of supply chain issues a lot of big brands um. Cut their promotions and you saw that retailers were then bringing in their competitors who were willing to spend more and get that shelf space um you know aside from the numbers would you make those recommendations that you should be spending just to to keep the budgets of the retailers of your customers up as well?

Kurt Kaiser [30:18] Um, well, the, so this, this year was certainly. You know, like no other, right? So I, I, I don't, I don't know that I have a clear answer for you on, on, on this kind of once, once in a lifetime event. Uh, what I would, would encourage you to do, like, uh, uh, you know, the, the negotiate side, right, if you know, if you have intelligence about how you're operating across your customer base, right, that's gonna help you make decisions and, and, and help with, with discussions with your customers.

Speaker 5 [30:55] Uh, high level on margin. So you were talking gross sales minus 25 trade spend, net sales, um. Just try a lot of debate with sales teams and salespeople as to what our, you know, what's our starting point, uh, for margin? Would it be 45, 55, if you're gonna spend that 25, uh, I think you mentioned netting out with a 20 left over, but, uh, this goes all over the place, whether we're with club or, or natural or grocery, but, uh, there seems to be some confusion among my team as to where our margin should be safe. Say for a natural channel before all. This nonsense.

Kurt Kaiser [31:41] Yeah, well, I would, I, I guess my advice would be that you're gonna have to back into that to some extent. Um, what I've heard, what, what I've, I've learned over the, over the years is that, uh, so I'm, I'm gonna first talk about um, gross margin, OK, like, uh, what I've understood to be a healthy gross margin in this business is, is 40%. That, that's, that's, uh, gross profit divided by net sales. OK. That's not the retailer margin, OK? Yeah. Gross margin, yeah. So that, that, um, that equation, that, that's what I've understood to be the target. Um, Now with, with uh was that the question internal margin or your customer margins yeah. Yeah. Does that ring true to anybody else here? 40% gross margin. I see some nouns.

Speaker 6 [32:41] I

Speaker 5 [32:43] Saying 40, you're gonna spend 25, you're left with 15 to cover

Kurt Kaiser [32:47] the rest. No, no, the, now the, um, that figure, so we're, we're talking apples and oranges here a little bit. That figure, uh, that gross margin figure, right, is, is an equation, right? Trade spending is a, is in the new, uh, denominator of that equation, right? So there's a little bit of math that you have to do. I'd be, I'd be happy to walk you through it in a paper and pencil example.

Speaker 6 [33:14] I, I actually have a follow on question. So, so for brands are you looking at like trade spend is obviously a part of marketing, but what percentage of revenue typically does a brand spend on marketing and then what percentage of that is trade spend and then is data and analytics part of that or is it outside of it?

Kurt Kaiser [33:43] Yeah, um. Good question, um. It's, it's been a while since I've been in the, the brand advertising, uh, space, but what I, what I do, what still feels true is that trade is a bigger number than brand advertising, right? So what So I, I don't, I, I don't know a total for you, but, um, well,

Speaker 6 [34:09] I'm thinking that marketing includes things like digital, Insta, community development, um. You know, sponsorships, things like that. I know trade spend's gotta be just a percentage of that.

Kurt Kaiser [34:22] Yeah, I, I would say it's, it's, uh, probably the biggest portion of that total, that total budget

Speaker 6 [34:29] of the marketing spend,

Kurt Kaiser [34:30] yeah, yeah, OK, and then the like data and like tools like us, it tends to be, um, not, not part of that budget. It's, it's, uh. Like an SGNA.

Speaker 6 [34:42] Oh wow, OK.

Kurt Kaiser [34:43] All right, expense, thanks, right? But, but, but again, if you think about it as an expense, then you, you know, you're looking at whatever the, the, the monthly figure is. If you think about it as how do you better manage this bucket of money that's 25% of your, of your gross revenue, puts in a little different light.

Speaker 2 [35:06] Alright, I think we'll wrap it up. If anyone else has questions, you'll be able to catch them both this afternoon and tomorrow out at their booth. Yes,

Kurt Kaiser [35:14] thank you very much, guys. Uh, as I said, it has been 18 months since I've done anything like this. So thank you for your patience with me. Uh, and we're, we've got a booth out front, and, uh, love to say hello. Thanks for coming.

Related Videos