Search across the BevNET CPG Media network including BevNET, Nosh, Brewbound, Taste Radio, Nombase and CPG Jobs.
Community Call: Stumped on Valuation? Talk to an Investor. SWAT Equity and FABID Break it Down

Transcript
Note: Transcripts are automatically generated and may contain inaccuracies and spelling errors.
Melissa Travers [00:05] Hello and thank you so much for joining us today. I am Melissa Travers, director of community here at Bevnet and Nosh, welcoming you to Community Call. Please join in the conversation, throw any questions or thoughts you have right in the chat, or you can turn on your video and audio to hop into the conversation live. I do want to let you all know, if you don't know already, that we've launched the Bevneet and Nosh Slack community. You can reach that at slack.bevnet.com and we can continue the conversation that we start here over there. And speaking of our conversation today, we will be talking about valuation with Ryan Williams of Fabid and Sarah Foley of SWAT Equity. You know, I have to say it's a real pleasure for me to be able to do these community calls because I learned so much in the process. And the evaluation topic can be so tricky, and I think sometimes founders feel like they need to know everything already and that asking questions is um makes you look like you don't know what you're talking about, but that is certainly not true at all. So we're here to talk about everything. If you have any questions, please ask them because, um, you know, day in and day out, all of you founders are working on your businesses, not Evaluating the value of it the way investors are, so ask all of the questions, please. Um, Sarah Foley, it's so great to have you here. Swat Equity invests in early stage high growth consumer brands. How is business going right now? What kind of investments are you making?
Speaker 2 [01:36] Mm, well, thank you very much for having me, Melissa, and it's such a pleasure to be here with Ryan, who's uh a favorite person of mine too. Um. How's it going? Um, mixed, I would say, really, and to be honest, which is why we're all here. Um, The environment for me the last 6 months really has slowed in terms of new companies that we've been looking at. Um, fewer companies out raising capital, um, and kind of the thresholds that we'd like to use to evaluate opportunity continue to tighten. And make sure that we're, you know, spending time on what we believe are the right sectors and then the kind of right businesses, the right brands that we want to look at within those sectors. Uh, but food and beverage has always been a big, big one. we honestly have not made a new food investment in a couple, maybe 3 years. So, there's been a lot of competition sprout up, pun intended, and then a lot of ways in which, you know, new products need differentiation in order to really stand out on the either physical or digital shelf. And that's where we really try to spend a lot of time making sure we understand the differentiation. There's, um, a real need, right, for that product to fit in the market, which is crowded. And we have ways in which we think about that, but the, the kind of long answer here is that the pipeline has slowed, kind of new pace of investment has slowed as we are looking for businesses that have been making the right kind of moves to scale their companies.
Melissa Travers [03:16] And I would think that at a time like this, getting everything right like valuation would be certainly beneficial.
Speaker 2 [03:26] It's always important to try to get valuation right, and that doesn't mean, and I want to be clear, that you have to reach the highest valuation every time you raise money. Um, and I think that's an important point to underscore here, because the higher the valuation. The, there could be real challenges raising a subsequent round of capital. So, if the valuation, you know, feels very peaky or stretched or rich, as we might call it, in a prior round, and the business doesn't necessarily, to be honest, catch up in terms of performance standards, right? Performance metrics that we'll look at to raise the capital. Later in a subsequent round, which could be 2 years away, and the market's shifted entirely like we're experiencing now. So, you've gotta be um Opportunistic in the moment, balanced, I would say, with making sure you're putting the company, the capital table on the right footing to raise a subsequent round successfully. Either closing it in general, right? Maybe it's flat, but is always desired, but you, you do, you don't want, I, I, I, I always advise companies to not get overly greedy in the moment. But really balance, you know, subsequent rounds, the right investors and the help those investors will bring to the kind of process.
Melissa Travers [04:55] Those are some great nuggets of information and we're gonna dig into all of those. Um, Ryan, thank you so much for joining. Uh, could you tell us a little bit about FABID? So FBID is the Food and Beverage Investor Database. Can you explain what FABID tracks and how?
Speaker 3 [05:12] Sure. Well, uh, first of all, thanks for having me, and, uh, Sarah, thanks for joining me on this. It was one of the first people in consumer venture that I met. So I appreciate you taking the time as well and excited to be here. Uh, Favit, as you said, it stands for the Food and Beverage Investor Database. We track, uh, every investor, every brand, every person, and every deal that kind of collectively comprises the, the CPG ecosystem with a Particular emphasis on food and beverage. And so, uh, if you can imagine someone, uh, you know, reading every SEC filing and Bevnet article and then organizing the whole thing into a nice, uh, little database or I guess it's now a nice big database, um, that's, that's what we've put together and, um, one component of that, uh, from the start was, was a lot of people asking, not just How much capital capital is being raised, but this even more opaque kind of component of great, you know, it's, it's up or it's down, it's this very absolute kind of thing where you can have a lot of metrics around it, but what terms are companies raising money on and specifically what valuations and there's certainly less data points, but it doesn't mean, you know, anyone needs to go into that process blind.
Speaker 2 [06:30] It's a gold mine, a gold mine of information that Ryan's got his hands on.
Melissa Travers [06:35] Excellent. Um, Ryan, can you give us a, a quick definition of evaluation? What, what factors does that number include?
Speaker 3 [06:43] Yeah, I mean, I guess in the simplest terms, it's, you know, how, how much is the equity value of, of the company that you're looking at, depending on how for now an early stage company is raising money and, and whether it's a safe or a convertible note or a price round valuation kind of becomes a little bit ambiguous of whether it's a cap or just truly the the value of the company, but I think there's a lot of things that go into deciding the number. I think there's. Macro conditions like how much capital is available and everyone has to remember that just as it's become so hard for brands to raise funding, it's also been hard for a lot of the investors to raise funding and so that has this trickle down effect that you can zoom out even further to rising interest rates and other things that just make uh capital less available and then specific to each company, there's, I think, a number of things that go into it. The, the team. The, you know, the management team, have they started and sold the company before, or is it their first time? Uh, what's the growth? Um, I think one that probably came up less than it should have over the last two years is what's the, what are the economics and margins and cash need of the company, you know, um, revenue obviously is, is one that's very easy to kind of center around, but I think there's, there's a number both kind of hard and soft, macro and micro things that collectively. You know, get you to the right number.
Melissa Travers [08:17] And is valuation set by founders or investors, or is it a little bit of a back and forth? Sarah, you wanna take that one
Speaker 2 [08:24] first? Uh, it, it's, it's, it's always a negotiation. Um, it's ultimately, right, as they say, what the market will bear in terms of where you settle on the overall valuation, um. But there are, you know, I think there are ways that you signal kind of range in order to get the conversation going. Uh, sometimes that conversation is, uh, harder to start in a more challenging market like we have today, uh, versus a free flowing capital coming from everywhere market that we had previously. Um, but, uh, I think You, as a founder, firstly need to make sure you are well advised legally, um, find the right counsel to help you navigate the process, uh, from the documents, etc. Um, that's really important, and it doesn't have to be the biggest law firm in the world or the country. There are a lot of great kind of practitioners out there, but you'd be surprised that some of the larger law firms that specialize in early growth investing will work with you for A pretty discounted number because they view you as a long-term client and want to work with you on their subsequent capital raises and your exit, and so on and so forth. So, please find a good lawyer, it's important to have. And then it's, you know, be informed, talk to your friends who have raised capital, see what they've experienced, um, and always be talking to investors. To get to know them outside the crazy frenzied part of raising capital in a round, um, so that you get to build a better dialogue, you get to build a better relationship with them to really understand what kind of partner they will be after they hopefully successfully close an investment in your round.
Melissa Travers [10:24] And in those conversations, what should brands be bringing up new product launches, financial health, like, what kinds of information should you be talking to an investor about maybe if you're not in the process of a raise?
Speaker 2 [10:39] Um, I'll throw in my two cents, and then I want Ryan to make sure he speaks to it as well, but, um, I kind of boil it down to just a, a lesson, probably a handful of things. Uh, one is, is your most obvious evidence of traction. So how is revenue growing? And what's the quality of the revenue? Meaning, What channels of distribution have you um found and are you proving out that might be only e-commerce, which is fine, but it may be a combination of e-commerce, Amazon, and a physical brick and mortar retailer. So, I think you've got to be prepared to describe how you're scaling, how you're planning to scale in the next 12 months across those different channels, and what are the economics that you're associating with that scaling. Um, we're gonna look at unit economics, right, on a product. We're gonna look at channel economics between your ecom, your Amazon, and physical, and we're gonna look at the particular retailer economics too, to make sure, you know, you're keeping all of those in mind before you start spending below, as they say, that line of gross margin on team and on other marketing efforts that you're using to build the brand. Um. Then we'll go into kind of how velocity is working, how fast things are moving around your product selling through, but we want to understand where's real product market fit, and do you actually have a sustainable kind of cost structure in place that can survive building.
Speaker 3 [12:16] Yeah, I think those are all great points, and I think like a lot of times, um, maybe some companies conflate, uh, not being able to get investor interest with the valuation being wrong, and I think a lot of times it's, it's really that's, that's the second step, and the first is that the company needs to be investable to begin with. So I, you know, I, I, I don't know if Sarah would agree with this, but for probably every 1010 deals or companies in our inbox and 9, there's probably almost no number uh evaluation that makes it worth evaluating and that, you know, that depends on what each investor is interested in, in, in different, um, you know, kind of companies and categories and such, but first, you have to kind of make sure, um, your company has, um, is investable and the best way to be investable is to have traction and the better you can articulate that, um, you know, I think you're gonna have a lot of success. The other thing I wanted to say is, um, as far as just kind of getting advice around valuation, I've seen a number of companies over the last, you know, 6 or 9 months that are going through this process. I think generally founders get pretty good advice from other founders that have recently raised from reputable firms or ones that have been in CPG for a while. I think there's also, um, you know, I would say proceed cautiously with. Um, referencing, uh, the, the very, very highest valuations that have been kind of publicly reported, you know, when you're a You know, middle of the pack brand, and I think being a little honest around that is, is important, so not comparing yourself to someone that's irrelevant. And I've also seen some cases where companies have advisors and while very well intentioned, they come from a completely different industry like tech or, you know, whatever. And I would make sure that the advice you're getting is Not just intuition led, but is from someone that's been part of this, you know, world for, for more than a month.
Speaker 2 [14:29] Directly relevant, is that what you mean?
Speaker 3 [14:32] Yeah.
Melissa Travers [14:33] Those are two great and very important points. First of all, um, you mentioned that the valuation isn't necessarily the first thing investors look at. You know, when us as consumers are shopping, usually one of the first things you look at is the price tag, but it sounds like that's not necessarily the first thing investors are looking at, so that's a great point. And then getting advice from people who are in the mix and who are, who, who have worked through the process. and know how things are working right now. So thank you for that. Um, let's see, Mike had a, uh, a comment which I totally, uh, I totally agree with. Ryan, you mentioned, um, the understanding valuation in, in safes versus convertible notes versus priced rounds. Um, what's the difference between a cap and a valuation, and can you pick apart those three different categories?
Speaker 3 [15:23] Sure, I'll, I'll start with uh safes and then we'll go to convertible notes, and then we'll go to price round. So there, I would say just generally for early stage, there's kind of these three structures that have emerged of how companies raise money. Um, the SAFE, which stands for Simple Agreement for Future Equity, is further subdivided between pre and post-money safes. And in the case of a post money safe, there's a cap which is essentially the maximum that the investment can convert at. And so if it's a million dollars on a $5 million post money safe, that tells the investor upfront that they're buying or buying 20% of the equity, 1/5, and the principle of a cap extends further into convertible notes, which is The concept that the money that comes into the company will convert into shares at a maximum valuation of something that's predefined. So if you set the cap at $10 million and the company waits 2 years and goes and raises the price around at a valuation of $40 million that earlier money converts at a at a cap, a max of what's agreed back when. And then moving on to price rounds, I think is Uh, documents wise, like the most complicated of the three, but, uh, understanding wise is maybe the most simple, which is just what's the pre-money valuation of this company and, you know, it's, I, it's kind of as intuitive as that, and Sarah, I don't.
Speaker 2 [17:03] No, that's right. Um, look, I think as an investor, we always prefer raising a round of money at a, in a priced equity round because it's simpler, and we know we're actually going to own something in the business, uh, which is a usually preferred stock, a preferred, you know, equity security. Um, that's great, it's comforting and again, it's very straightforward. X number of dollars is going in at this valuation and will end up owning Y percentage of the business, with tweaks around where the kind of management equity pool, option pool plays in, but that's kind of marginal around the whole valuation. That's what we prefer. Um, these bridges of capital, as what we've historically called them, are convertible notes and safe notes. Safe notes are just a basic simple piece of paper. That's really all it's worth to, whereas a convertible note is actually a dead instrument. Has an interest rate. It's not accruing at a cash rate. It's kind of just accruing in kind, but grows a little bit over time, and it's meant to be for a short period of time, a couple of years at the most. But it has a term at the end where there's a point where if you haven't converted it, you have to have a conversation with those investors and figure out what you're going to do. But historically those two pieces of those two tools were used to bridge a company for a short period of time as a big growth spurt was coming. They were launching in, you know, another channel or with a new retailer and wanted to make sure they had enough inventory available but didn't want to, couldn't necessarily borrow it yet from a real debt lender. They're usually smaller in size so that they don't have a larger dilutive effect when they ultimately do convert. But we ended up in this phase the last probably 5 years where they were kind of used as a preferred method to get around raises quickly, not have to go through a long paper document on an equity round and move on. Um, my advice to founders is Use them sparingly, use them in the correct circumstances, um, but think about their impact on dilution and valuation kind of expectation building as you want to go out and raise that subsequent round, which should be a larger and priced equity round. There's a lot in there, OK? So I know there is, this is the conversation, this is the language that I speak every day, kind of Ryan too, so it's natural, um, which is again why as a founder, go make sure you've got friends in the mix who've gone through the process and you've got some legal advice to make sure you're navigating the stuff that's important, um, and not worrying so much about the details because you haven't yet experienced and gone through these reps enough time to feel more comfortable.
Melissa Travers [20:01] I myself will need to watch this episode at least a couple times. Um, I have a, I have a question from Alex Cree, who wants to know for founders who have already taken a substantial dilution, maybe from prior pivots, that kind of thing, um, is that just tough luck, or do VCs entertain, um, and reinvest option pools for founders? So he's saying a lot of founders need to have meaningful equity in order to stay motivated, um. What, uh, how can VCs accommodate founders in these situations or, or what is that, what does that look like right now?
Speaker 2 [20:35] Well, you're absolutely right. We are, as part of the elements of assessing an opportunity and its merits and potential and, and return profile. We want to make sure management and founders are properly motivated. Um. Uh, we could have a long, we have a call along this alone, right, on what's the appropriate sizing of equity ownership by founders as subsequent rounds go through and there's a dilution that happens, as well as what's the size of an equity management kind of option pool that makes sense at various stages too. But the short answer is Um, yes, investors will look at how you can top up, as we kind of call it, an existing management option pool. Um, to make more available and ultimately dilute ourselves and prior investors too, but make sure it's in kind of the realm of reasonableness and market to give management team the tool they need to incentivize themselves as well as the other kind of folks they're going to need to bring into the business to execute against the plan. Um, so it happens. It happens often, I would say, and it's a conversation you shouldn't be afraid to bring up. Uh, but there's another tool out there that can be used, I think, as you get further on in building the business, and that could be more of a cash incentive pool too, where there's a bonus tied to exiting at a valuation, and it can ratchet up as the kind of valuation grows. I've seen that come into play. Uh, as well. Um, so, there are tools here that can address kind of what may be lower ownership than you'd like, uh, but please, you know, keep it real on, are you at a lower ownership because you've had to raise more capital than necessarily planned because some things aren't working in the company.
Melissa Travers [22:34] Great advice. Thanks for that question, Alex. Um, we've got a question from Namik Sultan who wants to know what you guys think about crowdfunding.
Speaker 2 [22:44] Ryan, do you want to go first?
Speaker 3 [22:47] Uh, well, you know, listen, I think innovation within a company, you know, how companies raise money is not a good thing for the economy and, and the ecosystem, and every company, you know, should pursue its own path to, uh, you know, to, to raise money. Um, I think that it struggles from a, a, a few things. Um, one, I think it becomes quite inflexible once you post. Your crowdfunding campaign and kind of set the terms around it. Uh, you can't really, you know, there's not much wiggle room there. I think it's more difficult to make a meaningful connection with a lead investor and kind of gain all the things that having kind of institutional capital in your, in your company provides. Um, I've seen there, there's benefits of it for some companies. I mean, one, frankly, I think, uh. You know, I, I maybe I'll just be more controversial than I should. Uh, there, there's definitely companies that are successfully raising, you know, fairly meaningful amounts of money, crowdfunding that I think would have that, that rightfully are not able to raise money, uh, through kind of institutional means, and I, part of me, you know, I, I see a company that has like 3 months of runway and has negative growth and all these things that are like, make it just frankly like an uninvestable company, and then they turn to crowdfunding and the valuations double what they were pitching to VCs and it, you know, candidly, it makes me feel a little bad for the retail investors that, you know, find it a shiny object, but I think. Honestly, or probably unlikely to ever, and I, and I would ask if that is, you know, it, perhaps a negative for, you know, uh, the, the industry, if, if that happens too much. Just, just my opinion.
Melissa Travers [24:41] And that's because the scrutiny with crowdfunding is certainly different than it would be if you were raising from investors, is that the idea?
Speaker 3 [24:49] Yeah, I mean, it's a call of 40. So I, I would say, I think some people approach crowdfunding with a perspective that it's the, like, dumb money. And I think, you know, I don't know. Uh, I think, I, I, I don't know if, if that's a, a good or, or, or a bad thing long term for the, for the industry and, um, yeah.
Speaker 2 [25:13] I think there are circumstances where It can work, um. And the two that come most to mind, firstly, I would say it's not, it's not used that often, um, but the couple of circumstances where I've seen it happen and at work is launching, um, it's kind of, uh, finding people who will see your new product as interesting and you are either crowdfunding to help raise the capital to build the product, and they buy it. Uh, they get their, their product and they own a little bit of, of equity in the business. Um, that's one way, and then another, another way I've seen it work successfully is if you've kind of built a community of early adopters and followers, you're raising around, uh, you've got a good chunk of it raised. But you might want to finish it and top it up with a little bit more that comes from that very supported, supporting community that uh invests at the same terms, right, as everybody else and kind of the more institutional capital that comes into the round. That I think is a fun way to employ crowdfunding into your cap table. Um, we kind of also call it SPV, uh, where you put a bunch of people who may be smaller investors into an entity, make it easier on the founder and the management of all of those investors coming in as one group instead of individuals. But they get this, you know, wonderful experience of being a supporter of not just buying the product, but being a small investor in the business, and that can be a very powerful kind of way to continue to expand your customer base.
Melissa Travers [27:04] Great perspective. Thank you for that. Laura Briscoe has a question that actually relates to a point that was brought up, Ryan, I think by you. Um, Ryan, you brought up multiple no man's land, for example, wanting to raise it 4 million with 250 in sales. How do you respond to an investor who says that's, you know, 16x multiple? That, that was what you said. I don't really understand it. Please expound.
Speaker 3 [27:29] Oh yeah, that was in our, uh, pre, pre. Show notes of things I've, I've thought about before. I mean, I, I would imagine most people on the call have watched the Shark Tank episode before where Kevin, you know, uh, blasts the company for raising it, you know, 100 times their net earnings or, you know, 70 times their revenue, but it's, it's a, it's, you know, the earlier you are, the less kind of metric-driven things can be, um, and I mean, of course, like if you're, if, if you've just started and you have zero revenue, I, I would argue. That the company isn't worthless and so, you know, the best way I've been able to conceptualize things is, is there kind of a base valuation for the long term opportunity here and that there's smart people involved pursuing something that can have a, you know, whatever the probability is times whatever the exit value can be times however long it's going to take to get there. Like what is that kind of. Original evaluation, so to speak. And then on top of that, sure, you have some traction of like, there, it should be additive. And I think what happens is sometimes people have, are new to market and they get kind of forced from, I'm investing purely in a concept and an opportunity to, now I want to look at this like it's a private equity deal, and I would try to bifurcate the two if I was a founder in that no man's or no woman's land.
Melissa Travers [28:56] Um, that, that makes perfect sense, I
Speaker 3 [28:58] think. Um,
Melissa Travers [29:00] going back to some of the sort of initial evaluation questions, how do you know if you got your valuation right or wrong? At what point during the process do you understand what the accuracy of the number is?
Speaker 2 [29:15] Uh Um Not to be glib, but I think, you know, the valuation ends up um settling where the market will bear, and that market is defined as you asking for the capital and an investor who's got to lead the conversation and negotiation on what's uh a valuation that we can both live with. That's really kind of what it comes down to. And there are 3 ways in which I think you, you kind of vector in on getting there. Uh, one is somewhat stage dependent. If you're pre-launch and you've got an idea, but you've got a lot of work to prove out the product and then get it to market, there's kind of a Range at which pre-revenue businesses are kind of valued, and it's between five-ish and seven-ish in our space, in kind of consumer packaged goods land. That's one kind of pillar. Uh, the next is, yes, if you've got some traction, what are some multiples as guidance that gets you into another data point of valuation, and that's going to be revenue driven because you don't have any income yet. You are losing money as you are scaling the business and investing in people, team, marketing, etc. And that range depends. It depends on the category, the subcategory you are, uh, and it depends on kind of how fast you've been able to grow. Um, so I'm not going to kind of give a range, but think of it as low to mid single digits on net revenue. And then the third, equally important in my opinion, is how much money do you need? How much money do you need to execute against a plan for the next 2 years? And generally, you're looking at selling between 15 and 25% of the equity in your company every time you go out to raise capital. So if you do that math, whatever the dollar amount is divided by 15% to 25%, you back into what your valuation range could look like. And then, you know, it's getting to know your capital partner, your larger investor or investors and the kind of incremental value they bring to help de-risk executing on that plan. And that's going to depend on what the kind of different pockets of value add that those investors bring to the table, but something that invests the founders should be diligencing just like we diligence a business.
Speaker 3 [32:00] I would, I would just add to that, like, I, I would think from a founder's position of like, did I get this right, um. And for, for some founders, it's like, did I, which Sarah kicked this call off by saying, did I find the absolute highest point that I was able to, you know, raise my amount at. So, you know, in, in economics, I think it's like a perfect price discrimination and the concept that like, if you sold your product, you could get one person to pay, you know, the, the maximum they're willing all across the board. But I, I think functionally, um, the way a founder should think about getting it right is Was I able to raise the, the total amount that I, that I needed for, you know, what, if you're raising for 2 years, did I get every dollar I needed? Um, did it, was it incredibly burdensome and took like 1 year to do it and it was a major distraction and along the way we ran out of inventory and 3 people quit, or did I Get it done and move on to putting my time back into growing things. So how, how long, uh, did it take me? Um, and then also, you know, maybe 3 to all of those is. Uh, the, the funds or the person or the, the people that I've ended up with, um, is the dilution that I've given up, uh, less, you know, meaningful, or was it, was it worth it relative to how much more I can, I can grow the, the pie with this amount. And I think if you, if you feel good about those three things, um, then, then I think you got it, you got it right.
Melissa Travers [33:33] Is there a drawback to to getting a valuation that's too high? Is, is that a thing?
Speaker 2 [33:40] Hell yeah.
Melissa Travers [33:41] So what's, what's the danger?
Speaker 2 [33:43] The danger is if you need to raise more capital. And The trajectory that the trajectory of the business doesn't continue to line up with that level of expectation on valuation. You run a high risk of having to raise capital. Below that prior evaluation round, uh, which is problematic because all of those other investors are going to be further diluted. Um, and it's a difficult position to negotiate from. So that's what I was referring to is you've got to be realistic about where you're raising current round in order to successfully raise the following round, um. And the earlier you are, you know, the more often you're going to have to raise capital, where you need it to support building the business and burn rate until you reach a place where you are profitable, and then you may want to raise more capital, but it's purely because you're going to supercharge marketing. You don't need to raise the capital.
Speaker 3 [34:45] Yeah, and I would, I would just say a cautionary tale, not just of successfully raising at a, at a valuation that then leads to a potential down round, but also just the downside of picking too high of a number or raising at a, at a valuation or attempting to in, in that particular 11, I think if it's absurd, and you, I don't know if Sarah would agree, but I think you actually see a higher percentage than you'd expect of a. Absurd valuations, absurd meaning, you know, a company doing a million dollars in revenue and wants to raise it $50 or something like that. Um, I think you end up, it reflects poorly on you as the CEO to not be aware that what you're asking for is, is absurd. So I think you should be just aware of, of, uh, yeah, of What it says if you and then the second thing, one other thing, there's good companies that I've seen raise at borderline absurd valuations because understandably they want to keep as much equity internally as they can. And so what happens is they kick off their round, they've got 6 months of runway to go, they want to minimize dilution and they set a number that's, you know, too high. And then 3 months go by, they've talked to every investor in the entire world and gotten all these intros, and even though it's a good company that's, as we said earlier, investable, it's not investable, that valuation, and now you have 2 months of runway, you've kind of, you know, maybe rub some people the wrong way. You've already had all your conversations, maybe the investors you've talked to. To have moved on with other things, whatever. And now, your previously good investable company is gonna be out of cash in 60 days. And if, if you need to adjust kind of intra around, that's obviously not great, and I, and you're not gonna be able to adjust to what it should be, you're gonna take an additional penalty of, cool, now you need this money and 60 days or whatever the number is, so I would, I would be cautious, and I've definitely seen that happen.
Melissa Travers [36:53] Can you, can you fix the image issue of, of coming to a valuation that's absurd with a little humble pie? Is that, can you go back to people and say, I totally messed this up. I, I, I've seen the light of day, or at that point, have you really sort of done some significant damage?
Speaker 2 [37:12] I mean, I think, you know, you, every everything is worth trying, and usually there's a good likelihood that you can fix it. Um, it gets more complicated as you have multiple rounds of capital raised with different kind of cost bases in there, if you will, in the most recent round. Um, of investors who are going to suffer, you know, the most with respect to where, how far down that next valuation happens.
Melissa Travers [37:45] Gotcha. Um, I see a, we have a lot of questions here and I don't know that we're going to get to all of them, but I will put these in the Slack channel and we'll try to get you some answers there because we only have about 5 more minutes. I see a question here from Paul. Hi, Sarah. What was the 5-ish and 7-ish multiples for pre-revenue companies? Was it projected net revenue? Over a certain period of time.
Speaker 2 [38:07] No, it's actually $5 million to $7 million not multiples. That was my example of there's one pillar of, here's just an absolute dollar range of valuation for pre-revenue, pre-launch business, OK, so kind of early, early, early. Once you've launched, then you start working with some metrics including what net revenue, and definitely I look at what net revenue multiples look like, and that very much differs between stage, early, category within food and Bev. Um, so I don't want, I don't want to commit to a range because it would sound absurd to Ryan's point, it would be very wide that you could drive a semi truck through. So, um, You, you have to do additional diligence to narrow down the, the kind of specificity that investors are going to think about with respect to your particular product category.
Melissa Travers [39:03] Great. I see another question from, I'm gonna butcher this name, I'm so sorry, Adamya Sharma. What is a good benchmark for revenue multiples for Series A beverage companies, um, top-notch brands and average brands if they, if they differ significantly?
Speaker 2 [39:18] Are you, Ryan.
Speaker 3 [39:20] Well, I mean, I'll, I'll throw out one that's like semi-public, you know, I think Liquid Death was their last round was like a $630 million pre, you know, I guess that counts as top notch. Uh, I think it was like an 8X LTM multiple. That's another thing that matters is the multiple, you need to. Everyone needs to be speaking the same language. So are we talking about the multiple on your trailing 12 months? Is it your trailing 12 months net revenue or gross? I think the most relevant is trailing 12 months net. Um, but sometimes, um, well, this is maybe a good thing to bring up. Um, I think, uh, trying to raise right now on multiples of anything forward looking is, I think, may maybe I wouldn't put in the bucket of absurd, but unless you have like. Spins data backing up the velocities of the category, confirmed like retailer distributions and all of those things. Um If, if I, if I was working for Sarah, um, like, I, I would, I'd find it really silly for someone to say, invest in me, so I can get to a milestone, but then value me based on the milestone that I need the money to get to, like, that doesn't make sense. So, you can push, you can kind of put that in the mix a little bit, but definitely LTM and to give it, uh, I, I've kind of arrived at, you know, I think. 3 or 3.5x seems to be kind of median market right now. I'm, I'm gonna keep
Speaker 2 [40:47] talking in beverage
Speaker 3 [40:49] in beverage, um, maybe it flexes a little bit from there, um, but you know, 3.5 x 43, there's so many variables and you know, I, I would be weary of giving a number 2.
Melissa Travers [41:06] I'm going to squeeze one last question in here from Alex again. Why are down rounds a problem in this market?
Speaker 2 [41:14] Why are they a problem? Um, Alex, if you
Melissa Travers [41:19] wanna, if you wanna turn your video and audio on real quick and, um, and give us a little more information. Feel free. Um, yeah, there you go. Hi Alex.
Speaker 4 [41:32] Hey, yeah, look, I mean, straight up, um, market's tight. I mean, most, most of these brands are struggling to raise anything, right? And I think most cap tables, most investors, even most boards are, are like, hey, get any money you can right now. I don't think anybody cares about the down rounds. They're, they're looking for cash to keep their companies alive, and they're looking for their brands to stay relevant and, and remain operational, right? Totally agree. So, you, you know, I, I don't think the down rounds that, that big of a problem. I don't even think it's that big of a black eye. It's really macro driven even, right? So, you know, the question then though is, I think a lot of these founders are looking at down rounds. I think it's a bigger problem for the founders than it is for their cap table and their prior investors, you know, and it's like, I think that a lot of the
Speaker 2 [42:20] delusion they may
Speaker 4 [42:21] suffer. That's, that's the biggest thing, you know, at a certain point, founders have to stay relevant and so when, you know, looking at valuation. You know, we've been looking at a lot of comps and things. It's like, realistically, it's more of a cost push even than a demand pull. You can look at multiples of revenue and things like that. I think most founders want to just capitalize their business and remain relevant themselves, because if you dilute under whatever 10% ownership or, you know, something ridiculous. There's really nothing much left for you at the end. So why, why even go through with the raise? Why not just close shop? So that's, that's kind of my broader point is like, maybe the down rounds aren't the big, the, the problem from the, the, you know, legacy investor standpoint, and maybe the valuation is not even that much of a problem from the founder's standpoint. It's just that, you know, there's tools to, you know, uh there's tools to kind of navigate through that. And I, I guess my, my question is just, you know, it kind of relates back to my prior questions like, OK, what can, what can investors then do to get into a negotiation where it's like, OK, we know what you need, and we know what the founder, we, we know what the business needs, and we know ultimately what the founders need to stay relevant or feel relevant. You know, how can, how can investors create more of a valuation negotiation maybe around that. Um, and again, the multiple revenue growth, quality of product, all that stuff is kind of cost of entry, but, um, you know, it seems like there's a lot of people throwing it in, or at least offering Alex,
Melissa Travers [43:59] I'm so sorry to cut you off. I know we're, we're just about out of time, but I want to get you an answer before we totally run out of time. Um, Ryan and Sarah got a, got a quick few words before we're totally out of time. Thank you so much for that.
Speaker 2 [44:13] Uh, no, you're absolutely right, Alex. We're in this transitionary time where, uh, you, survival is kind of paramount instead of valuation being paramount. So, um, the kind of deal of the du jour is the inside around at probably in some kind of largely abridged type of scenario through one of those two securities. Um, and you figure it out and you kind of kick the can, uh, through 2024 to build the runway that you need to demonstrate additional growth, traction, etc. and have that kind of honest conversation about as this investor groups getting ready for raising that next round, what are we going to do to make sure we top up the option pool, put some other incentives in place, and I think, you know, those are the conversations you've got to be having and laying the groundwork around now.
Melissa Travers [45:00] Thank you so much for that. I've gotten so much from you both already. One last request before we hop off. I would love to hear from each of you very quickly. What's your best advice for founders right now, Sarah? You're on the money side of the table. You see it all from the investor's perspective. How can founders come to this process and, you know, valuation and investing from a point of strength?
Speaker 2 [45:24] Aside from, you know, making sure their businesses are performing well, um, You know, look, I think my, I guess my piece of advice would be, this is a long game. Don't rely on just this next round, just these next kind of terms to determine how successful the overall business will be eventually. Um, so, uh, you know, do what you need to do to buy the time with additional capital to extend your runway for, uh, you know, at least to 2024 and come back to market when we believe things will have improved and you'll have made some more progress.
Melissa Travers [45:59] Excellent. Ryan, how about you? What's your, what, what's your advice for founders right now?
Speaker 3 [46:04] I think survival is key. The number of stories I've heard of companies making a big exit after just managing to make it through, you know, a trough of the market, or just the business overall is, is a, is a longer one than you'd think. Um, and I think just having the same empathy or thinking of things with investors just like you think of them maybe as a retailer of you're not talking to like a loan officer, you're, you're pitching them of how it's going to work for them and I think a little bit more some founders should approach things with You know, pretending they're the investor in their own business. And if you can kind of enter a conversation with that perspective, I think you'll do a better job of pitching your deal, and I think you'll have a lower risk of proposing something that leads you to not getting one to begin with.
Melissa Travers [46:54] Great stuff. Um, for folks who may have questions that they didn't get to ask, what's the best way to get in touch with both of you? Is it LinkedIn or something else?
Speaker 2 [47:02] Yeah, LinkedIn for me.
Speaker 3 [47:04] Excellent. LinkedIn's great.
Melissa Travers [47:06] There you go. Thank you both so much. Thank you all so much for the questions. Those were great and they really add to the quality of the show, so thanks for those. We, I will, um, address any questions that we didn't get to on the show on our Slack channel. You can find that at slack.bevnet.com and we can tackle those there. We will make a tape recording of this call available at bevnet.com/communitycall. You can sign up for future calls there as well. Next week we've got the marketing folks from C4 and NutriBullet. They're going to talk about field and experiential marketing and their formula for successful external events, no matter what stage of growth you're at, and we'll also be trying a different format of a show with Vasa Martinez, founder of Pury, to answer his questions on structuring beverage multipacks and negotiating broker contracts. So thank you all so much again for joining us. Such a pleasure, and we'll see you next time.